Paul Thomas Anderson's Punch-Drunk Love (2002) is a romance-comedy following themes of love, anxiety, and courage, as Barry (Adam Sandler) must overcome his own social anxiety to go out with Lena. To convey this, Anderson employed sound, colour, framing, and many more sensorial elements, while deliberately leaving a lack of dialogue. In this essay, I will be focusing on colour in the mise-en-scène, editing, and sound, which all come together to create a sensory experience, making the viewer feel the unstable or intense emotions that Barry is going through. Colour is not only able to set the tone for a scene, but can also be paired with psychology to become a symbol for characters and recurring themes. Editing allows the filmmaker to control exactly what the viewer is seeing, when that is, and the speed at which it is seen. This controls emotion much more than one may think, raising viewers' heart rates just by raising the speed of cuts. Finally, the film uses sound as a replacement for dialogue at points, making the film seem more realistic in its conversations. By doing this, they can show that the anxiety is only affecting the character of Barry, not the workers, his sister, or Lena. But this aspect does not isolate Barry; it actually makes viewers feel closer to him as they are the only ones who can hear this non-diegetic sound, spiking their own anxiety too. Through these three formal elements, we are constantly shown emotions of calm love or high anxiety, putting these onto the viewer to draw them further into the work and the character of Barry. We see the use of colour in the wardrobe and lighting to convey this in almost every scene, as well as changes in the speed of editing and sound to reflect these emotions. Punch-Drunk Love prioritizes a sensory experience over narrative and dialogue-based storytelling to construct an emotionally intense and at times unstable tone, through sound, mise-en-scène, and editing, putting these emotions not only onto Barry but the audience as well. 

​

   Colour can be used as symbolism in film, and Punch-Drunk Love most definitely employs it. Barry wears a blue suit, the same one he wears for the duration of the film, and Lena wears a red dress, symbolizing love or passion. Barry's suit is meant to reflect the anxiety that he is trapped in, and by using a suit as the symbolizer, he can change. These changes are shown by flashes of red throughout the film, starting with the car that crashes right before the harmonium first gets dropped off at 2:05, Lena, of course, umbrellas and carpets in Hawaii, and Barry's ties. Barry's ties change throughout the film from blue to yellow, orange, dark red, and finally bright red when he decides to go to Hawaii, showing his evolution of gaining courage and breaking out of his anxiety over the course of the film. 

​

   The scene that was most interesting to me when it came to colour was 49:08-51:27, when Lena and Barry leave the restaurant and drive home. For the first half until 50:04, there is no dialogue, just Lena and Barry walking to their car, allowing the audience to truly feel the characters' emotions, as if they were with them awkwardly walking down the street on a first date. Because of this, the viewer is forced to analyze the formal elements; Lena and Barry both represent two different ends of the same emotion, love. As the two are dressed in red and blue, the background is filled with the same colours, showing the audience their emotions through psychology, red for love or passion, and blue for sadness or anxiety. Once in the car, we switch between feeling anxious for Barry as Lena asks questions, to feeling hopeful that Barry will choose to open up to her, playing with these two ends of love, and allowing the viewer to feel as if they are also on the hot seat. 

   At 31:28 to 41:39, we see a good example of high anxiety showcased in this film. At the start of the scene, Barry walks into his workplace after previously receiving some threatening news. Composer Jon Brion has layers of different drums and beats in his score here, starting with very few layers and a medium speed bpm, raising the speed and amount of layering as people keep trying to talk to Barry, adding more stress and anxiety to his day. This allows sound to take control over the action of the scene, aiding in the realism of the conversation, showing how anxiety builds in real life. We reach a peak of anxiety when the intimate phone line operator calls him back at work, while his sister and Lena are trying to take him out for breakfast, with the diegetic crashing of stock or supplies at the warehouse on top of some of the fastest and loudest music in the scene to back this. We finally come to a calm when Lena comes back inside to ask Barry out, and this loud, almost interrupting music fades into the background as they are finally alone at 40:42, representing the theme of love and calmness Lena symbolizes as a parallel to Barry's anxiety and anger. 

​

   These emotions or sense of anxiety are put onto the audience through interpretation, supported by Susan Sontag's Against Interpretation. In it, she states, “Real art has the capacity to make us nervous. By reducing the work of art to its content and then interpreting that, one tames the work of art” (Sontag 5). When viewers watch this scene, there is not a lot to work off of besides sound and dialogue, but funny enough, the dialogue does not really matter in this scene until the end, when the music fades out. So if we use this knowledge plus Sontag's quote, we can better understand that by ignoring the dialogue, just as Barry is doing, the viewer can “tame” the scene and better understand his viewpoint. 

    The final scene I would like to talk about is the kiss scene when Barry visits Lena in Hawaii (65:00-67:12). The editing of this scene is different from that of others in the film, being much slower paced, emphasizing love over anxiety. When Barry finally gets through to Lena on the phone at 65:00, the phone booth lights up, marking a turning point in his emotional state. This moment is paired with He Needs Me by Shelley Duvall, a slow and gentle song that contrasts sharply with Brion’s fast-paced, percussive score used in earlier scenes. As Barry arrives at the hotel, the editing begins to be more continuous, personal, and much less fragmented, pulling away from rapid cuts and tension building. This gives viewers more time to take in the scene, drawing out their emotions, but with love and excitement rather than anxiety this time around. 

​

   When Barry and Lena finally meet, he reaches out to shake her hand, but she pulls him in for a kiss. This creates an unexpected contrast between the anticipation and resolution of this action, paralleling Sergei Eisenstein's theory that emotion comes from the juxtaposition of opposing elements. In A Dialectic Approach to Film Form, Eisenstein states that “montage is an idea that arises from the collision of independent shots-shots even opposite to one another” (4 Eisenstein). This idea helps explain the contrast in this scene, the lighting drastically changes to a heavy backlight, something we never see again in the film, with tons of hotel patrons walking around them, causing busyness that has not been shown in the film's world until now. This creates emotional meaning through opposition, the pair standing still versus the patrons moving, and the scene having no visual similarities to the rest of the film. Here, Anderson abandons the instability that follows Barry and the viewers throughout the film, replacing it with calmness to finally give viewers a sense of relief. 

   Punch-Drunk Love is an example of formal elements working together to build an emotionally intense experience, straying away from a traditional narrative. To focus on a more sensory experience, Anderson employed colour, sound, and editing, making the viewer truly feel Barry's anxiety, anger, and eventual happiness, instead of having viewers observe the character, he attempts to recreate Barry’s emotions within them. The constant use of red and blue as symbolism shows viewers Barry's emotional journey, using mise-en-scène as a psychological tool over aesthetic detail. Editing and sound both set the pace and flow, employing quick cuts and layered percussion to make this sense of anxiety even stronger. Contrasting this is a slower pacing and a softer sound being used in later scenes to give Barry and the audience a sense of calmness. This truly brings viewers onto the rollercoaster of emotions our protagonist goes through, using the form itself as the narrative structure. In conclusion, Punch-Drunk Love prioritizes the physical watching of the film over following the dialogue, by using formal elements that construct an emotionally intense and at times unstable tone, through sound, colour, and editing, putting the audience into Barry's blue suit. 

​

Primary Sources: 

Eisenstein, Sergei. “A Dialectic Approach to Film Form.” Harcourt, Brace & World, 1949, pp. 1-16. chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://moodle.concordia.ca/moodle/pluginfile.php/7842663/mod_resource/content/1/Eisenstein-A%20Dialectic%20Approach%20to%20Film%20Form.pdf. 

Sontag, Susan. “Against Interpretation.” Against Interpretation: And Other Essays, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1966, pp. 3-14. chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://moodle.concordia.ca/moodle/pluginfile.php/7867564/mod_resource/content/1/Sontag.pdf. 

​

Secondary Sources: 

​

Bordwell, David, et al. Film Art: An Introduction. 13th Ed ed., McGraw-Hill Education, 2023, Chapter 4, pp. 118-124, Chapter 6, pp. 219-230, Chapter 7, pp. 265-292, Chapter 11, pp. 402-421. 

​

Corrigan, Timothy. “A Short Guide to Writing about Film, 9th ed.” Pearson, 2015. 

file:///Users/brookelawrence/Downloads/Timothy%20Corrigan%20-%20A%20Short%20Guide%20to%20Writing%20about%20Film%20(2014,%20Pearson)%20(1).pdf. 

​

Luna, Melissa. “Exposing the Interior Through Sound in Uncut Gems and Punch-Drunk Love.” ASPECT Journal of Film and Screen Media, 2025. University of North Carolina, https://aspectfilmjournal.web.unc.edu/2025/01/luna-exposing-the-interior-through-sound-in-uncut-gems-punch-drunk-love/. 

​